Hack Forums
Kindly Rate this - Printable Version

+- Hack Forums (https://hackforums.net)
+-- Forum: Tech (https://hackforums.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=444)
+--- Forum: Graphics (https://hackforums.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=156)
+---- Forum: Rate My Graphic (https://hackforums.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=133)
+---- Thread: Kindly Rate this (/showthread.php?tid=5446581)

Pages: Pages 1 2 3

Kindly Rate this - Motusora - Oct 28, 2016

did this for my client .. however I still want to hear your opinions.
critiques and comments are welcome 🤝

thanks !!!

Spoiler (Click to View)
https://i.imgur.com/sq99ucU.jpg

* - Mr. Robot - Oct 28, 2016

I would personally say 6.5/10.

I just feel like all 3 elements don't "quite" merge together. They work alright and get the job done though :)

* - FunnyHands - Oct 28, 2016

(Oct 28, 2016 05:03 AM)Motusora Wrote:  did this for my client .. however I still want to hear your opinions.
critiques and comments are welcome 🤝

thanks !!!

Spoiler (Click to View)
https://i.imgur.com/sq99ucU.jpg

I'd say about a 8/10, the art style is slightly too off put for my style, but overall it's well put together. The logo is hella nice

good work OP

* - Motusora - Oct 28, 2016

(Oct 28, 2016 05:05 AM)Mr. Robot Wrote:  I would personally say 6.5/10.

I just feel like all 3 elements don't "quite" merge together. They work alright and get the job done though :)

thank you for your honest opinion , any advice ? 🤝

* - SIM-964740 - Oct 28, 2016

One thing I did notice is that you didn't continue your trace on the characters wrist: [Image: 1f2e0928d4096f4276aa2465070ed77a.png] Looks like it is his arm bulging out at a distance.

* - Motusora - Oct 28, 2016

(Oct 28, 2016 08:38 PM)Selcouth Wrote:  One thing I did notice is that you didn't continue your trace on the characters wrist: [Image: 1f2e0928d4096f4276aa2465070ed77a.png] Looks like it is his arm bulging out at a distance.

yeah . i noticed that too ... thank you 🤝

* - problems.x - Oct 28, 2016

i like it i think you're talented buddy


(can u msg me too, i habent msged u and cba but can u msg me cause i might need ur work soon.)

* - Motusora - Oct 28, 2016

(Oct 28, 2016 08:46 PM)Incapability Wrote:  i like it i think you're talented buddy


(can u msg me too, i habent msged u and cba but can u msg me cause i might need ur work soon.)

sent you a pm man !

* - patflexx - Oct 28, 2016

I do think that a completely blurred background does give it a little bit of an odd feel to it, But there are a few uses where this would actually be what you are looking for. For general use, as a marker or "stamp" if you want to call it that, I would give it a little but more depth of field if its possible, taking it from completely extracting the foreground character and logo and giving it a bit more of a "pseudo-realistic" feel that might be more attractive. However I can think of decent uses for both styles, pros and cons of each, and it all depends on what you and your client were aiming for. Vector isn't the easiest thing in the world to do without losing some of these realism factors. I wouldn't be able to responsibly rate unless it was put into context, but there is no need, as your work is Impressive for sure!


Edit* Fyi I'm more of a photographer, so that inevitably impacts how I go about thinking of things like this.

* - Motusora - Oct 28, 2016

(Oct 28, 2016 10:14 PM)patflexx Wrote:  I do think that a completely blurred background does give it a little bit of an odd feel to it, But there are a few uses where this would actually be what you are looking for. For general use, as a marker or "stamp" if you want to call it that, I would give it a little but more depth of field if its possible, taking it from completely extracting the foreground character and logo and giving it a bit more of a "pseudo-realistic" feel that might be more attractive. However I can think of decent uses for both styles, pros and cons of each, and it all depends on what you and your client were aiming for. Vector isn't the easiest thing in the world to do without losing some of these realism factors. I wouldn't be able to responsibly rate unless it was put into context, but there is no need, as your work is Impressive for sure!

thank you for the detailed comment sir 🤝 .. any other suggestions ?

* - igneous27 - Oct 29, 2016

(Oct 28, 2016 05:03 AM)Motusora Wrote:  did this for my client .. however I still want to hear your opinions.
critiques and comments are welcome 🤝

thanks !!!

Spoiler (Click to View)
https://i.imgur.com/sq99ucU.jpg



Linis pre !!! try mo nextime magdagdag pa ng layers para sa shading mas magiging maangas tingnan yan !! 🤗🤗

* - Motusora - Oct 29, 2016

(Oct 29, 2016 07:52 PM)igneous27 Wrote:  Linis pre !!! try mo nextime magdagdag pa ng layers para sa shading mas magiging maangas tingnan yan !! 🤗🤗

depends on the payment mate , $10btc lang yan tapos may kulang pa syang $5btc .
ano sya sineswerte ? 🤭

* - Jordsguy - Oct 30, 2016

very nice vector art i can see you spent time on it im very impressed

* - Jamiec - Oct 30, 2016

I think this is awesome! :) Feel free to make me a sig hehe

* - Motusora - Oct 30, 2016

(Oct 30, 2016 12:19 AM)Jordsguy Wrote:  very nice vector art i can see you spent time on it im very impressed

yeah , i guess about 1-2 hours .