Home Upgrade Search Memberlist Extras Hacker Tools Award Goals Help Wiki Contact

Defrag: How much is too much?

(Dec 17, 2015 04:42 PM)Knowledgeable Wrote:  ok sounds good thank you for the input
👍
Your very welcome, i'm happy to help out answer your question.🤝
i will pm you about something else, hoping you can help me with that, it'd be appreciated
Never ever defrag an SSD, it won't give you any performance boost whatsoever and will directly affect life expectancy of the SSD. However, if your drive is an HDD, you might as well uninstall Defragger because Windows defrags your HDD once a week anyhow, which should keep you around that magical 5% range.
(Dec 19, 2015 04:50 PM)BLURRYFΛCE Wrote:  Never ever defrag an SSD, it won't give you any performance boost whatsoever and will directly affect life expectancy of the SSD. However, if your drive is an HDD, you might as well uninstall Defragger because Windows defrags your HDD once a week anyhow, which should keep you around that magical 5% range.

what about a flash drive or external seagate drive?
don't try to defrag those either right?
(Dec 19, 2015 06:33 PM)Knowledgeable Wrote:  what about a flash drive or external seagate drive?
don't try to defrag those either right?
Flash drives, no, external HDD's, yes, external SSD's, no.
So i have a 3TB external seagate with a few system backups on it... you're saying it's safe to defrag that? Should I?
(Dec 19, 2015 07:14 PM)Knowledgeable Wrote:  So i have a 3TB external seagate with a few system backups on it... you're saying it's safe to defrag that? Should I?
Giving us the brand name of storage drive does not help us know if the drive SSD or HDD as seagate manufacture both them.
If the 3TB external seagate Solid State Drive (SSD) then no don't defragment the storage drive.
You should use third party defragmenters software they arrange data much better then Windows Defragmenter also some of them can do boot time defragmentation and free space defragmentation.
Check out free "Smart Defrag" software.

"Smart Defrag"
http://www.iobit.com/en/iobitsmartdefrag.php
(Dec 19, 2015 09:37 PM)Freebooter Wrote:  Giving us the brand name of storage drive does not help us know if the drive SSD or HDD as seagate manufacture both them.
If the 3TB external seagate Solid State Drive (SSD) then no don't defragment the storage drive.
You should use third party defragmenters software they arrange data much better then Windows Defragmenter also some of them can do boot time defragmentation and free space defragmentation.
Check out free "Smart Defrag" software.

"Smart Defrag"
http://www.iobit.com/en/iobitsmartdefrag.php
The size should give you some idea, considering it's a consumer device.
P.S. It's a HDD.
I have O&O defrag now as it's top rated and so far I'm liking it much more than Defraggler but Defraggler worked very well.
O&O also has a boot time defrag and free space cleaner.
Also, I'm pretty sure the big external is not an SSD. It's an external requiring a power adapter and everything.
(Dec 19, 2015 09:56 PM)Knowledgeable Wrote:  I have O&O defrag now as it's top rated and so far I'm liking it much more than Defraggler but Defraggler worked very well.
O&O also has a boot time defrag and free space cleaner.
Also, I'm pretty sure the big external is not an SSD. It's an external requiring a power adapter and everything.
Well why don't you check manufacturer website to find out if external drive is SSD or not probably not i'm sure its HDD but make sure its. Power adapter and other everything whatever they are does not indicate which kind of external storage you are using what make you thing externel SSD runs without power adapter.
I'm pretty confident it's an HDD to be honest but yeah I can always check.
But why is it a good idea to defrag an external HDD? Haven't quite heard of that being before but doesn't mean it shouldn't be done i guess.
(Dec 20, 2015 09:23 PM)Knowledgeable Wrote:  I'm pretty confident it's an HDD to be honest but yeah I can always check.
But why is it a good idea to defrag an external HDD? Haven't quite heard of that being before but doesn't mean it shouldn't be done i guess.
How have you not understand all storage drives store data and they get fragmented so why do you thing external HDD somehow store data different than internal HDD. You defragment all HDD.
I never took a minute to actually think about the fact that the external seagate drive would actually be an HDD with a spinning drive. It makes sense now that it's acknowledged but it just didn't occur me in that way. I guess I just saw it as an external storage similar to a flash drive but it would make sense it's much more than a flash drive.


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
by Scar3croWMar 24, 2011 06:02 PM 7 106 Mar 24, 2011 06:02 PM
Last Post: Eminent Fate