[Mets08123]

Here it is: [IMG]http://imgboot.com/images/Mets08123/alice.png[/IMG]

Please rate ?/10 and CnC! thanks :D

[koi]

the render should be brought out more, the way the smudge is on her head and left arm makes it look sloppy. i like the subtext but the main see throught text with stroke doesnt work. needs some lighting and darken the edges. the smudge settings should be varied. not just one continuous stroke

6.5/10

[sтаяsкï]

Koi's a smudge pro now? lts a stock not a render XD
You've over blended the focal, your lightsource is on the wrong side lol & use a different smudge brush this ones ugly lol

[koi]

no smudge pro. i cant smudge, i dont recognize the stock so i did not know, however it doesnt mtter either way, like u said its ugly, the smudging needs different variations blah blah blah

[Mithiril]

Horrible smudge
Horrible splatter
Horrible text
Work the render, fix her light.

[Asatru]

The background needs some work other than that 8.5/10.

[alps]

Good effort, but you haven't done much to it other than smudging the edges outwards, try to use filters and gradient maps, as well as c4d effects, one thing I do like is the text, keep it up 5/10 from me :)

[pseud0]

you youngins should watch a movie call blue lagoon 2 milla is in it shes about 17 and she is fucking SEXY (and you catch a glimpse of her boobs/booty)...oh cool sig :)

EDIT: Apologies for not leaving an appropriate response, i didn't see the requested format.

5/10 - based on: The background is way to simple IMHO. I think you could have really gone crazy, I just like to see people really challenging themselves...I also think the little brushes that i believe are little light overlays around your focal image are a little intense and random...but, the text is diamond.

[Legend™]

^ LoL, I like the comment you made there before you talked about the signature. Anyways pseud0 is a graphics and web design god from what I've seen so far.

[Perforate]

7/10 well done desinging it everythings fits together very well.