[Tsukaima]

Even though the anime came out last year it still has a lasting impression :P

Does anybody know any animes that are similar or very close in genre?
Accepting randoms too but heres a very unupdated list to see what else I like!

http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Rakaino

[Dark Neko]

Hmm I've heard that Mawaru Penguindrum is some similar in some aspects but I've yet to watch it.

Other anime you might like:

Code Geass
Romeo x Juliet (Also has things based off Shakespeare)
Death Note
Clannad After Story (I really recommend watching this after Clannad)
Lovely Complex
Mirai Nikki (Make sure you watch the Redial OVA)

[Phaxol]

http://myanimelist.net/anime/14075/Zetsu...t/userrecs

Recommendations from people who have seen it as I have not seen it.