Home Upgrade Search Memberlist Extras Hacker Tools Award Goals Help Wiki Contact

Trezor or Ledger

What exactly is the better for security/privacy, I know they use fairly recent software/hardware/practices however never touched either.

If youre going to reply I do ask that you provide a product that youre talking of (primarily wallets), although not required would be nice so I can make my mind up. It would be nice to hear thoughts of people who personally use a hardware wallet and their own thoughts or whatever.

Going to spend around £100 - £150 as I dont exactly need something stupidly new or high tech just want something very secure and can hold its own in the wild.

----

I have been eyeing the Trezor 5 seems worthy of the price maybe.


-------------------------------------

Thank you guys for the advice on both and your views, personally think the trezor is best for me and my values. Thank you all.
I have nothing really of value to say because in my mind, security wise they both offer top notch products and comparing the security wouldn't really make a difference unless the Mossad is after you. But if you're going to choose a Ledger please for the love of god don't get one with a battery, or at least don't get a Nano X. I'm on my second one because of battery issues and have also heard and read about this from other people so many times now too.
(Jan 7, 2026 08:28 AM)Kify Wrote:  I have nothing really of value to say because in my mind, security wise they both offer top notch products and comparing the security wouldn't really make a difference unless the Mossad is after you. But if you're going to choose a Ledger please for the love of god don't get one with a battery, or at least don't get a Nano X. I'm on my second one because of battery issues and have also heard and read about this from other people so many times now too.

Yikes thought something as highend as this would have good batteries. Ill keep that noted. Ironic.
Go for Trezor, I think recently exodus added compatibility with it as well.
(Jan 7, 2026 08:43 AM)m0hx Wrote:  Go for Trezor, I think recently exodus added compatibility with it as well.

Suggestions? Is the 5 really that much better over the 3 and worth the near 140 tag?

Also nice exodus likes it.
(Jan 7, 2026 08:43 AM)m0hx Wrote:  Go for Trezor, I think recently exodus added compatibility with it as well.

ledger has exodus too
A long long time ago, like 2015-ish, the Trezor leadership team said some really dumb stuff that was basically them trying to downplay a pretty critical flaw in their hardware model. I haven't touched or even considered Trezor since then. They've very likely come to their senses and are in good standing now, but I've never washed the bad taste from my mouth.

I own a few Ledger devices. Don't use them as much as I should, but no complaints. Easy to use.

(Ledger as a company are also far from perfect)
Had a Ledger brick on me trying to firmware update.

I bought Trezor after that, no problems. I like the wallet better too.
(Jan 7, 2026 10:28 AM)SUI-3183372 Wrote:  A long long time ago, like 2015-ish, the Trezor leadership team said some really dumb stuff that was basically them trying to downplay a pretty critical flaw in their hardware model. I haven't touched or even considered Trezor since then. They've very likely come to their senses and are in good standing now, but I've never washed the bad taste from my mouth.

I own a few Ledger devices. Don't use them as much as I should, but no complaints. Easy to use.

(Ledger as a company are also far from perfect)

Both companies have their issues like all companies do nowerdays it seems.

ANother dude said ledger has battery issues so I am likely going to stay away from certain models.

(Jan 7, 2026 10:35 AM)Omniscient Wrote:  Had a Ledger brick on me trying to firmware update.

I bought Trezor after that, no problems. I like the wallet better too.

How much did you lose? did you end up recovering? Thats stupidly unlucky this might be a nail in the coffin for ledger. One of them.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00R6M...15API&th=1

Older model but it's $18, you can't beat that.
(Jan 7, 2026 10:36 AM)Biggy_Asian Wrote:  How much did you lose? did you end up recovering? Thats stupidly unlucky this might be a nail in the coffin for ledger. One of them.

You have the seed phrase from the wallet. I lost nothing. But it was the aggravation and I spent hours on the device trying to fix it. Do you know how aggravating it is to use that tiny screen and 2 buttons to scroll through a gazillion seed words to reinstall the firmware? I must have done it 10-15 times before I just gave up. Still have the f'n thing, it's useless to me though. It tells me I'm required to update the firmware to connect to latest wallet but the hardware won't update, it crashes. Super F'n aggravating. And I got like no support on it, they should have offered to replace it for me but they didn't. I just think these clowns are retards and the Nano is a shit product by a shit company with shit support.

I'm sure Trezors have been broken security wise but usually that does require them to have access to your hardware. I have no plans on having my Trezor accessed by anyone but me.
(Jan 7, 2026 10:36 AM)Biggy_Asian Wrote:  ANother dude said ledger has battery issues so I am likely going to stay away from certain models.

I have a Ledger Nano (Now known as Ledger Nano Classic) and a Ledger Stax (Newest model). I've never experienced any battery issues with either of them.
(Jan 7, 2026 10:43 AM)Omniscient Wrote:  You have the seed phrase from the wallet. I lost nothing. But it was the aggravation and I spent hours on the device trying to fix it. Do you know how aggravating it is to use that tiny screen and 2 buttons to scroll through a gazillion seed words to reinstall the firmware? I must have done it 10-15 times before I just gave up. Still have the f'n thing, it's useless to me though. It tells me I'm required to update the firmware to connect to latest wallet but the hardware won't update, it crashes. Super F'n aggravating. And I got like no support on it, they should have offered to replace it for me but they didn't. I just think these clowns are retards and the Nano is a shit product by a shit company with shit support.

I'm sure Trezors have been broken security wise but usually that does require them to have access to your hardware. I have no plans on having my Trezor accessed by anyone but me.

Fully aware of the phrase. Other hand thats just completely stupid, trust me ive been there in really bullshit situations using a box of scrap in a cave like tony stark.

I am sure alot of things are prone to being broken or breached somewhat in terms of physcial access I mean theres nothing you can do ab that but like you said (we both) you plan on protecting it and so do I.

I live around a < 6m walk ~ 3-5m run till I get to a few bridges with alot of water under, I can then dump my shit into the sea if I needed. I also have trains and shit near so I can just go follow the tracks and hide my trezor or smth . Just many possibilities.

(Jan 7, 2026 10:53 AM)SUI-3183372 Wrote:  I have a Ledger Nano (Now known as Ledger Nano Classic) and a Ledger Stax (Newest model). I've never experienced any battery issues with either of them.

Issues can happen for whatever reason true. Idk tho apart for that they seem to have not the greatest support though from what ive read. Not replacing a bricked nano for omni is kinda shit i will be honest.

(Jan 7, 2026 10:38 AM)Omniscient Wrote:  https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00R6M...15API&th=1

Older model but it's $18, you can't beat that.

dang bro £14 not bad, lemme see if a newer model is on here and lets see what i can snag :D Forgot amazon has basically everything despite the clones lol
btw about a Trezor Model One ($18) vs Trezor 3 ($80)

AI Quote: Here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide whether [Trezor Model One]() at ~$19 is a good deal and whether it’s worth spending more on a newer model like the Safe 3 (~$80) instead:

🔐 Trezor Model One (~$19) — Great Budget Pick



Pros
Low price — if you can get it for around $19, that’s a steal compared to typical retail (~$49).
Solid security basics — offline private key storage, PIN + passphrase protection, works with major cryptos. ([trezor.io][1]) Trusted entry-level hardware wallet that’s been around for years with strong community support. ([Milk Road][2])

Cons

Older hardware — uses micro-USB rather than USB-C, and the screen/buttons are basic. ([The Bitcoin Hole][3]) Not as future-proof as newer models.
Some tokens (like XRP, SOL, ADA, XMR) may not be supported without workarounds or external tools. ([trezor.io][1])

👉 Best for you if:
✔ You’re new to hardware wallets and want cheap, secure cold storage.
✔ You’re just storing major cryptos and don’t need fancy features.

🔄 [Trezor Safe 3](https://trezor.io/trezor-safe-3-cosmic-b...hatgpt.com) (~$79–$80) — A Better Long-Term Wallet



Pros
Modern security upgrades: newer USB-C, improved secure element, and stronger hardware protections. ([Bitbo][4])
Better coin & token support and broader compatibility. ([BitDegree][5]) Easier to use and more future-proof than Model One.

Cons

Higher price than the Model One — but still a good value in the mid-range hardware wallet space.

👉 Best for you if:
✔ You plan to hold a wider variety of assets (beyond basics).
✔ You want long-term reliability, better hardware security, and modern connectivity.

🧠 Which Should You Buy?



📉 If price is the main factor


Yes — $19 for a *Trezor Model One is a fantastic deal if the device is new and authentic (strongly avoid used devices with unknown history). It will keep your keys offline safely. Just know it’s older tech and less convenient compared to newer options.

📈 If security & future use matter



The Safe 3 for around $80 is worth the extra money if:

You hold more crypto, plan to grow your portfolio, want broader coin support, and prefer USB-C/modern features.
You’re planning long-term storage and want better hardware support.

🔒 Extra Tips


Always buy hardware wallets from trusted sellers (manufacturer, authorized retailers). Used wallets can be tampered with. ([buybitcoinworldwide.com][6])
The private recovery seed is what truly controls your funds. The device itself can be replaced as long as you keep the seed safe. ([trezor.io][7])

Bottom line:
📍 $19 Trezor Model One = excellent deal if you just want secure basics.
📍 $80 Safe 3 = better long-term choice with newer hardware and more features.

Want me to compare Trezor vs Ledger or other wallet options at similar price points? (Could help if you’re deciding the best value overall.)

[1]: https://trezor.io/trezor-model-one?srslt...hatgpt.com "Trezor Model One | The Original Crypto Hardware Wallet"
[2]: https://milkroad.com/reviews/trezor/?utm...hatgpt.com "Trezor Hardware Wallet Review 2025 - Fees, Features, & ..."
[3]: https://thebitcoinhole.com/hardware-wall...hatgpt.com "Trezor Model One vs Trezor Safe 3"
[4]: https://bitbo.io/tools/trezor-safe-3-vs-...hatgpt.com "Trezor Safe 3 vs Trezor Model One"
[5]: https://www.bitdegree.org/crypto-wallet-...hatgpt.com "Trezor Safe 3 vs Trezor One Crypto Wallet Comparison"
[6]: https://buybitcoinworldwide.com/wallets/...hatgpt.com "TREZOR One Review: 5 Things to Know (2024 Updated)"
[7]: https://trezor.io/learn/security-privacy...hatgpt.com "Trezor hardware: built-in security"




I'm going to grab 2 of those Model Ones today. That price is amazing and I basically just need BTC support.
(Jan 7, 2026 11:19 AM)Omniscient Wrote:  btw about a Trezor Model One ($18) vs Trezor 3 ($80)

AI Quote: Here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide whether [Trezor Model One]() at ~$19 is a good deal and whether it’s worth spending more on a newer model like the Safe 3 (~$80) instead:

🔐 Trezor Model One (~$19) — Great Budget Pick



Pros
Low price — if you can get it for around $19, that’s a steal compared to typical retail (~$49).
Solid security basics — offline private key storage, PIN + passphrase protection, works with major cryptos. ([trezor.io][1]) Trusted entry-level hardware wallet that’s been around for years with strong community support. ([Milk Road][2])

Cons

Older hardware — uses micro-USB rather than USB-C, and the screen/buttons are basic. ([The Bitcoin Hole][3]) Not as future-proof as newer models.
Some tokens (like XRP, SOL, ADA, XMR) may not be supported without workarounds or external tools. ([trezor.io][1])

👉 Best for you if:
✔ You’re new to hardware wallets and want cheap, secure cold storage.
✔ You’re just storing major cryptos and don’t need fancy features.

🔄 [Trezor Safe 3](https://trezor.io/trezor-safe-3-cosmic-b...hatgpt.com) (~$79–$80) — A Better Long-Term Wallet



Pros
Modern security upgrades: newer USB-C, improved secure element, and stronger hardware protections. ([Bitbo][4])
Better coin & token support and broader compatibility. ([BitDegree][5]) Easier to use and more future-proof than Model One.

Cons

Higher price than the Model One — but still a good value in the mid-range hardware wallet space.

👉 Best for you if:
✔ You plan to hold a wider variety of assets (beyond basics).
✔ You want long-term reliability, better hardware security, and modern connectivity.

🧠 Which Should You Buy?



📉 If price is the main factor


Yes — $19 for a *Trezor Model One is a fantastic deal if the device is new and authentic (strongly avoid used devices with unknown history). It will keep your keys offline safely. Just know it’s older tech and less convenient compared to newer options.

📈 If security & future use matter



The Safe 3 for around $80 is worth the extra money if:

You hold more crypto, plan to grow your portfolio, want broader coin support, and prefer USB-C/modern features.
You’re planning long-term storage and want better hardware support.

🔒 Extra Tips


Always buy hardware wallets from trusted sellers (manufacturer, authorized retailers). Used wallets can be tampered with. ([buybitcoinworldwide.com][6])
The private recovery seed is what truly controls your funds. The device itself can be replaced as long as you keep the seed safe. ([trezor.io][7])

Bottom line:
📍 $19 Trezor Model One = excellent deal if you just want secure basics.
📍 $80 Safe 3 = better long-term choice with newer hardware and more features.

Want me to compare Trezor vs Ledger or other wallet options at similar price points? (Could help if you’re deciding the best value overall.)

[1]: https://trezor.io/trezor-model-one?srslt...hatgpt.com "Trezor Model One | The Original Crypto Hardware Wallet"
[2]: https://milkroad.com/reviews/trezor/?utm...hatgpt.com "Trezor Hardware Wallet Review 2025 - Fees, Features, & ..."
[3]: https://thebitcoinhole.com/hardware-wall...hatgpt.com "Trezor Model One vs Trezor Safe 3"
[4]: https://bitbo.io/tools/trezor-safe-3-vs-...hatgpt.com "Trezor Safe 3 vs Trezor Model One"
[5]: https://www.bitdegree.org/crypto-wallet-...hatgpt.com "Trezor Safe 3 vs Trezor One Crypto Wallet Comparison"
[6]: https://buybitcoinworldwide.com/wallets/...hatgpt.com "TREZOR One Review: 5 Things to Know (2024 Updated)"
[7]: https://trezor.io/learn/security-privacy...hatgpt.com "Trezor hardware: built-in security"




I'm going to grab 2 of those Model Ones today. That price is amazing and I basically just need BTC support.

honestly might just go with a 3, might not need a 5 so far plus will leave me with around 30-60 in crypto to expunge.

Honestly 90 isnt bad at all, especially when expecting to spent an extra like 40-60.

Personally hate micro usb too

[Image: image.png]


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
by Mewtwo20 hours ago 6 122 20 hours ago
Last Post: bubblebutt
by wheeeee7777Oct 4, 2026 04:07 AM 2 79 Oct 4, 2026 04:07 AM
Last Post: SUI-3183372
by SUI-3183372Oct 3, 2026 01:27 PM 6 177 Oct 3, 2026 01:27 PM
Last Post: Dark Skin